ClearPiqClearPiq
🗄️

Best NAS Enclosures 2026

Diskless home & small-office NAS enclosures compared on ClearPiq-verified price per bay, real network speed, usable RAID 5 storage, and which models can actually hardware-transcode 4K Plex — independent UK data

8 products compared

How much storage do you need?ClearPiq storage calculator

Drag the slider to your target usable capacity. Each unit shows whether it can reach it — today, with an expansion unit, or not at all — using its maximum supported drive size.

20TBusable · in RAID 5
RAID level
3+ drives · tolerates 1 failure

6 of 8 models can deliver 20TB in RAID 5 today.

Synology
DS223j
RAID 5 needs 3+ drives — not possible on this unit
QNAP
TS-233
RAID 5 needs 3+ drives — not possible on this unit
Synology
DS423
Needs 7TB+ drives in all 4 bays
UGREEN
NASync DXP4800 Plus
Needs 7TB+ drives in all 4 bays
Synology
DS925+
Needs 7TB+ drives in all 4 bays
QNAP
TS-464
Needs 7TB+ drives in all 4 bays
Synology
DS1522+
Needs 5TB+ drives in all 5 bays
Synology
DS1821+
Needs 3TB+ drives in all 8 bays

Usable capacity assumes every bay is filled with each unit's maximum supported drive size (from the manufacturer's compatibility list). RAID 1 = single mirror · RAID 5 = one parity drive · RAID 6 = two parity drives. Real capacity varies with the drives you actually install.

Understanding RAID — which should I choose?

RAID (Redundant Array of Independent Disks) combines the drives inside your NAS so they work together — to protect your data if a drive dies, to go faster, or to pool several drives into one big volume. The level you choose decides how much usable space you get and how many drive failures you can survive.

RAID is not a backup. RAID protects against a drive failing. It does not protect against accidental deletion, ransomware, corruption, a power surge, theft, or fire — in all of those it faithfully copies the problem across every disk. Always keep a separate backup too (3 copies, on 2 types of media, 1 kept off-site). Treat RAID as uptime insurance, not your only copy.

RAID 0 — Striping (speed, no safety). Splits data across all drives for fast reads/writes and keeps 100% of capacity, but has zero redundancy — one drive fails and everything is lost. Only for scratch/temporary data. Min 2 drives.

RAID 1 — Mirroring (the simple safe choice). Writes an identical copy to two drives. You get the capacity of one drive (half your raw space) and can lose one drive with no data loss. The standard for 2-bay home NAS. Min 2 drives.

RAID 5 — Striping with single parity (the popular all-rounder). Spreads data plus one drive’s worth of parity across all drives. Usable capacity = all drives minus one; survives one drive failure. The most popular choice for 4-bay-and-up NAS. Note: rebuilding very large drives takes hours and stresses the rest, leaving a window where a second failure would lose the array. Min 3 drives.

RAID 6 — Striping with double parity (safer for big drives). Keeps two drives’ worth of parity: you lose the capacity of two drives but survive two failures at once — including a second failure during a rebuild. Sensible once you’re on large (16 TB+) drives or storing hard-to-replace data. Writes slightly slower than RAID 5. Min 4 drives.

RAID 10 (1+0) — Mirror then stripe (fast and resilient, pricey on space). Pairs drives into mirrors then stripes across them — speed and redundancy, but only half your raw capacity. Survives at least one failure, more if you don’t lose both halves of a pair. Popular for VMs and databases. Min 4 drives.

SHR — Synology Hybrid RAID (beginner-friendly). Synology-only. Manages RAID for you and lets you mix drives of different sizes while using space efficiently. SHR-1 tolerates one drive failure (like RAID 1/5); SHR-2 tolerates two (like RAID 6). Usually the easiest starting point on a Synology unit.

JBOD — Just a Bunch Of Disks (max space, no protection). Concatenates drives into one large volume with no redundancy and no speed benefit; only useful for combining odd-sized drives. Avoid for anything you care about.

Usable capacity & fault tolerance (example: 4 × 8 TB = 32 TB raw)

RAID levelMin. drivesUsable (4 × 8 TB)Failures survivedBest for
RAID 0232 TB (100%)0Speed only — disposable data
RAID 128 TB (2-drive set)12-bay home NAS
RAID 5324 TB (n − 1)14-bay+ all-rounder
RAID 6416 TB (n − 2)2Large drives / important data
RAID 10416 TB (50%)1+ (not both of a pair)Speed + safety (VMs, databases)
SHR-11–224 TB*1Beginners, mixed drive sizes
SHR-2416 TB*2Beginners wanting extra safety
JBOD132 TB (100%)0Max capacity, no protection

* SHR matches RAID 5/6 capacity with same-size drives; its advantage shows when mixing drive sizes.

Which should I pick? On a 2-bay NAS use RAID 1 (or SHR-1 on Synology). On 4-bay+, RAID 5 / SHR-1 is the sweet spot; step up to RAID 6 / SHR-2 once drives are large or the data is hard to replace. Use RAID 0 or JBOD only for data you can afford to lose. Whichever you choose — keep a real backup as well.

Showing 8 of 8 products
Some figures below — including running costs and real-world performance data — are calculated by ClearPiq and are not available on any manufacturer's website. Learn how →
SPEC / FILTER
Synology
DS223j
View deal →
QNAP
TS-233
View deal →
Synology
DS423
View deal →
UGREEN
NASync DXP4800 Plus
View deal →
Synology
DS925+
View deal →
QNAP
TS-464
View deal →
Synology
DS1522+
View deal →
Synology
DS1821+
View deal →
Rating
½4.5½4.5½4.5½4.5½4.5½4.5½4.5½4.5
OVERVIEW
Price (diskless)
£205.99£199.00£339.92£495.99£563.34£636.00£719.00£949.97
Drive bays
22444458
Max drive size (per bay)
20TB20TB20TB32TB24TB24TB20TB24TB
Form factor
Desktop towerDesktop towerDesktop towerDesktop towerDesktop towerDesktop towerDesktop towerDesktop tower
Operating system
DSM 7.2QTS 5.2DSM 7.2UGOS ProDSM 7.2QTS 5.2DSM 7.2DSM 7.2
CLEARPIQ DATA
★ Price per bay
£103.00£99.50£84.98£124.00£140.84£159.00£143.80£118.75
★ Max single-client speed
100 MB/s100 MB/s100 MB/s1000 MB/s250 MB/s250 MB/s100 MB/s100 MB/s
★ Max RAID 5 usable (20TB drives)
RAID 5 n/aRAID 5 n/a60TB60TB60TB60TB80TB140TB
PROCESSOR & MEMORY
Processor
Realtek RTD1619BARM Cortex-A55Realtek RTD1619BIntel Pentium Gold 8505AMD Ryzen V1500BIntel Celeron N5105AMD Ryzen R1600AMD Ryzen V1500B
CPU cores
44454424
RAM (installed)
1GB2GB2GB8GB4GB8GB8GB4GB
RAM (max supported)
1GB2GB2GB64GB32GB16GB32GB32GB
ECC memory
RAM type
DDR4 (onboard)DDR4 (onboard)DDR4 (onboard)DDR5 SO-DIMM (on-die ECC)DDR4 ECC SODIMMDDR4 SO-DIMMDDR4 ECC SODIMMDDR4 ECC SODIMM
STORAGE
M.2 NVMe slots
00022222
M.2 purpose
Cache + storage poolCache + storage poolCache + storage pool (Qtier)Cache + storage poolCache + storage pool
RAID types supported
SHR, RAID 0/1, JBODRAID 0/1, JBODSHR, RAID 0/1/5/6/10, JBODRAID 0/1/5/6/10, JBODSHR, RAID 0/1/5/6/10, JBODRAID 0/1/5/6/10, JBODSHR, RAID 0/1/5/6/10, JBODSHR, RAID 0/1/5/6/10, JBOD
Drive compatibility warning
Use CMR drives only for RAID. Recommended: Seagate IronWolf, WD Red Plus, Toshiba N300. Avoid WD Red (non-Plus) — uses SMR recording on 2-6TB sizes, causing severe RAID rebuild failures.Use CMR drives only for RAID. Recommended: Seagate IronWolf, WD Red Plus, Toshiba N300. Avoid WD Red (non-Plus) — uses SMR recording on 2-6TB sizes, causing severe RAID rebuild failures.Use CMR drives only for RAID. Recommended: Seagate IronWolf, WD Red Plus, Toshiba N300. Avoid WD Red (non-Plus) — uses SMR recording on 2-6TB sizes, causing severe RAID rebuild failures.Use CMR drives only for RAID. Recommended: Seagate IronWolf, WD Red Plus, Toshiba N300. Avoid WD Red (non-Plus) — uses SMR recording on 2-6TB sizes, causing severe RAID rebuild failures.Use CMR drives only for RAID. Recommended: Seagate IronWolf, WD Red Plus, Toshiba N300. Avoid WD Red (non-Plus) — uses SMR recording on 2-6TB sizes, causing severe RAID rebuild failures.Use CMR drives only for RAID. Recommended: Seagate IronWolf, WD Red Plus, Toshiba N300. Avoid WD Red (non-Plus) — uses SMR recording on 2-6TB sizes, causing severe RAID rebuild failures.Use CMR drives only for RAID. Recommended: Seagate IronWolf, WD Red Plus, Toshiba N300. Avoid WD Red (non-Plus) — uses SMR recording on 2-6TB sizes, causing severe RAID rebuild failures.Use CMR drives only for RAID. Recommended: Seagate IronWolf, WD Red Plus, Toshiba N300. Avoid WD Red (non-Plus) — uses SMR recording on 2-6TB sizes, causing severe RAID rebuild failures.
Hot-swappable drives
Third-party HDD/SSD supported
Max bays (with expansion unit)
22449201518
NETWORK
Max network speed
1GbE1GbE1GbE10GbE2.5GbE2.5GbE1GbE1GbE
Network ports
11222244
USB 3.2 Gen 1 ports
21232224
PCIe expansion slot
Expansion unit support
SMB Multichannel
SOFTWARE & OS
Time Machine support (macOS)
★ Plex hardware transcoding
Included backup client licences
Unlimited (Synology Active Backup)Unlimited (QNAP HBS 3)Unlimited (Synology Active Backup)Basic (UGREEN Backup)Unlimited (Synology Active Backup)Unlimited (QNAP HBS 3)Unlimited (Synology Active Backup)Unlimited (Synology Active Backup)
Docker / containers
Virtual Machine Manager
IP camera licences (included)
2822822
Warranty
2 years2 years2 years2 years3 years2 years3 years3 years
PHYSICAL
Noise (idle, dB)
18.2 dB20.6 dB29 dB20.5 dB22.9 dB22.2 dB
Power (HDD active, W)
16.31 W10.81 W32.41 W42.36 W37.91 W40.54 W52.06 W59.8 W
Dimensions (W × H × D mm)
100 × 165 × 225.591.7 × 185.9 × 157.5168 × 184 × 230177.8 × 177.8 × 256.5199 × 166 × 223170 × 168 × 226.1230 × 166 × 223343 × 166 × 243
Weight (diskless, kg)
0.88 kg1.69 kg2.21 kg2.26 kg2.26 kg2.7 kg6.0 kg

Prices are RRP and may vary. Specs verified July 2026. Some links are affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.